Sensible Trade Overhaul

Since the release of version 1.17 the trade has remained untouched, aside few minor additions. The concept of making the trade system more complex is a fine addition to the game, however the offers itself shifted balance dramatically, it became almost mandatory to set master tiers for certain villager profession (smiths for diamond tools and armour, librarian for enchantments, farmer for golden carrots) as it is most efficient way to complete the equipment in game now.

Solution is to turn the trade to more of a auxiliary than main source of income, give more purpose to other professions and establish more stable and intuitive economy.

Technical details:

This datapack requires VillagerConfig to work properly.

It can be freely added, updated or removed from Minecraft save, however you may need to refresh trade list for each villager. "Locked" trades will not be changed.

Despite Config being built on Fabric you can launch it on Forge via Connector.

Summary

Spoiler

• Removed Diamond tier from weapon and armour offers;
• Repurposed professions to reward players with convienent, yet fair trades;
• Modded trading system resembles "lesser effort, lesser reward";
• Introduced renewable source of important resources (e.g. sand, iron, diamonds, sponge).

Trade Stock

Spoiler

• Tools, enchanted books and rare items can be bought in much lesser amount (varying between 3-8) in comparision to regular items (16-32 cycles);
• Enchanted weaponry and armoury can be bought only once per stock;
• The stock amount can be disabled via VillagerConfig.

Proficiency leveling

Spoiler

• Villager with limited trade offers (e.g. Cartographer, Smiths, Fisherman) require less trades to level up;
• Costly trade offers provide more experience to the villager, to give a reason for choosing them over cheaper offers;
• Generally faster leveling process.

Trade Offers list

Spoiler

Armourer

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 18 Coal - 1 Emerald
• Chainmail Helmet - 5 Emeralds
• Chainmail Chestplate - 9 Emeralds
• Chainmail Leggings - 7 Emeralds
• Chainmail Boots - 4 Emeralds

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 4 Iron Ingots - 1 Emerald
• 36 Emeralds - Bell
• Iron Helmet - 7 Emeralds
• Iron Chestplate - 12 Emeralds
• Iron Leggings - 10 Emeralds
• Iron Boots - 6 Emeralds

Journeyman

Spoiler

• Lava Bucket - 1 Emerald
• 8 Emeralds - 3 Iron Ingots
• 9 Emeralds - Iron Horse Armour

Expert

Spoiler

• Ench. Iron Armour Leggings - cost respective to enchantment
• Ench. Iron Armour Boots - cost respective to enchantment

Master

Spoiler

• Ench. Iron Armour Chestplate - cost respective to enchantment
• Ench. Iron Armour Helmet - cost respective to enchantment

Butcher

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 32 Bowls - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 6 Raw Rabbits
• 1 Emerald - Rabbit Stew

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 15 Charcoal - 1 Emerald
• 2 Emeralds - 5 Cooked Muttons
• 2 Emeralds - 7 Cooked Rabbits
• 3 Emeralds - 8 Cooked Chicken

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 4 Red/Brown Mushrooms
• 1 Emerald - Mushroom Soup

Expert

Spoiler

• 4 Emeralds - 5 Cooked Porkchop
• 4 Emeralds - 5 Cooked Beef
• 1 Emerald - 3 Bones

Master

Spoiler

• 16 Ice Blocks - 1 Emerald

Cartographer

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 24 Papers - 1 Emerald
• 7 Emeralds - Empty Map
• 10 Emeralds + Paper - Flower Banner Pattern

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 3 Amethyst Shards
• 5 Emeralds - Brush
• 13 Emeralds + Compass - Ocean Explorer Map

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Candles
• 7 Emeralds - Spyglass
• 14 Emeralds + Compass - Woodland Explorer Map

Expert

Spoiler

• 5 Emeralds - 2 Soul Lanterns
• 32 Emeralds + Paper - Globe Banner Pattern

Master

Spoiler

• 64 Emeralds + Paper - Creeper Banner Pattern
• 56 Emeralds + Paper - Thing Banner Pattern
• 48 Emeralds + Paper - Skull Charge Banner Pattern

Cleric

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 32 Rotten Fleshes - 1 Emerald
• 24 Spider Eyes - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 2 Redstone Dusts

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 3 Gold Ingots - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - Lapis-Lazuri
• 8 Emeralds - Night Vision Potion

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 12 Emeralds - Water Breathing Potion
• 16 Magma Cream - 1 Emerald
• 8 Blaze Powder - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 3 Glowstone Dust

Expert

Spoiler

• 8 Glass Bottles - 1 Emerald
• 16 Emeralds - Strenght Potion
• 12 Emeralds - Swiftness Potion

Master

Spoiler

• 24 Nether Warts - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - Bottle of Experience
• 24 Emeralds - Regeneration Potion

Farmer

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 16 Wheat - 1 Emerald
• 48 Wheat Seeds - 1 Emerald
• 24 Potatoes - 1 Emerald
• 12 Beetroots - 1 Emerald
• 18 Carrots - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 4 Breads

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Apples
• 3 Emeralds - 4 Pumpkin Pies
• 6 Pumpkins - 1 Emerald

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 16 Cocoa Beans - 1 Emerald
• 16 Eggs - 1 Emerald
• 4 Melons - 1 Emerald

Expert

Spoiler

• 4 Emeralds - Cake
• 3 Emeralds - 2 Honeycombs
• 3 Emeralds + Glass Bottle - Honey Bottle

Master

Spoiler

• 24 Chorus Fruits - 1 Emerald
• 12 Sweet/Glow Berries - 1 Emerald

Fisherman

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 12 Strings - 1 Emerald
• 10 Charcoal - Empty Map
• 1 Emerald - Raw Cod/Salmon

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald + 6 Raw Cod/Salmon - Cooked Cod/Salmon
• 3 Emeralds - Campfire
• 4 Emerald - Fishing Rod

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 6 Tropical Fishes - 1 Emerald
• 4 Pufferfishes - 1 Emerald
• 6 Emeralds + Bucket - Bucket with Tropical Fish

Expert

Spoiler

• Ench. Fishing Rod - cost respective to enchantment
• 5 Emeralds - 4 Prismarine Shards/Crystals

Master

Spoiler

• 24 Emeralds - Sponge
• 8 Emeralds + Bucket - Bucket with Tadpole

Fletcher

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 48 Sticks - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - 16 Arrows
• 1 Emerald + 8 Gravel - 8 Flint

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 16 Flints - 1 Emerald
• 5 Emeralds - Bow
• 8 Emeralds - Crossbow

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 2 Emeralds - 3 Fireworks
• 3 Emeralds - 4 Gunpowder

Expert

Spoiler

• Ench. Bow/Crossbow - cost respective to enchantment

Master

Spoiler

• 8 Emeralds - 3 Fireworks (Yellow, Purple and White variation)

Leatherworker

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 3 Emeralds - 4 Leather
• 4 Leather - 1 Emerald
• Leather Helmet - 1 Emeralds
• Leather Chestplate - 4 Emeralds
• Leather Leggings - 3 Emeralds
• Leather Boots - 1 Emeralds

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 2 Emeralds - 3 Leash
• 1 Emerald + 16 Dirt - 16 Mud
• 1 Emerald + 18 Papers - 6 Books

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 3 Emeralds - 8 Rabbit Hides
• 8 Emeralds + 6 Arrows - 6 Slowness Arrows
• 12 Emeralds + 6 Arrows - 6 Weakness Arrows

Expert

Spoiler

• 6 Emeralds - Leather Horse Armour
• 16 Emeralds + 6 Arrows - 6 Poison Arrows
• 24 Emeralds + 6 Arrows - 6 Harming Arrows

Master

Spoiler

• Ench. Leather Boots - cost respective to enchantment
• 6 Emeralds - Saddle

Librarian

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 24 Papers - 1 Emerald
• 12 Emeralds - Bookshelf
• Enchanted Book - cost respective to enchantment

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 4 Books - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - 2 Lanterns
• Enchanted Book - cost respective to enchantment

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 5 Ink Sacs - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 4 Glass Blocks
• Enchanted Book - cost respective to enchantment

Expert

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Book and Quill
• 5 Emeralds - Clock
• 4 Emeralds - Compass
• Enchanted Book - cost respective to enchantment

Master

Spoiler

• 20 Emeralds - Nametag

Mason

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 12 Clayballs - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - 8 Bricks

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 32 Stone Blocks - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - 4 Stone Bricks
• 1 Emerald - Decorated Pot

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 24 Basalt Blocks - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - 4 Red Sandstone/Sandstone/Cobbled Deepslate

Expert

Spoiler

• 12 Quartz - 1 Emerald
• 3 Emeralds - 4 Terracotta/Bricks Block

Master

Spoiler

• 3 Emeralds - 8 Sand/Red Sand/Gravel

Shepherd

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 4 White/Black Wool
• 1 Emerald - 3 Brown/Gray Wool
• 6 White Wool - 1 Emerald

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Black/White/Red/Yellow Dye
• 1 Emerald + White Wool - 4 Strings

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Blue/Green Dye
• 4 Emeralds - White Bed

Expert

Spoiler

• 1 Emerald - 2 Brown Dye
• 1 Emerald - 3 Purple Dye
• 3 Emeralds - White Banner

Master

Spoiler

• 2 Emeralds - 3 Painting
• 14 Emeralds - Goat Horn

Toolsmith

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 15 Coal - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - Stone Axe/Pickaxe/Shovel/Hoe

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 14 Iron Nuggets - 1 Emerald
• 4 Emeralds - Bucket
• 3 Emeralds - Shears

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 7 Emeralds - Iron Axe
• 7 Emeralds - Iron Pickaxe
• 6 Emeralds - Iron Shovel
• 6 Emeralds - Iron Hoe

Expert

Spoiler

• Ench. Iron Shovel/Hoe - cost respective to enchantment

Master

Spoiler

• Ench. Iron Pickaxe/Axe - cost respective to enchantment

Weaponsmith

Spoiler

Novice

Spoiler

• 15 Coal - 1 Emerald
• 1 Emerald - Stone Axe/Sword

Apprentice

Spoiler

• 14 Iron Nuggets - 1 Emerald
• 5 Emeralds - Shield

Journeyman

Spoiler

• 7 Emeralds - Iron Axe
• 6 Emeralds - Iron Sword

Expert

Spoiler

• Ench. Iron Axe/Sword - cost respective to enchantment

Master

Spoiler

• 48 Emeralds - Diamond

Wandering Trader

Spoiler

• Enchanted Book - cost respective to enchantment
• 4 Emeralds - Bucket/Compass
• 3 Emeralds - Shears
• 3 Emeralds - 4 Leather
• 7 Emeralds - Spyglass/Empty Map
• 8 Emeralds - Night Vision Potion
• 12 Emeralds - Water Breathing Potion
• 16 Emeralds - Strenght Potion
• 12 Emeralds - Swiftness Potion
• 10 Emeralds - Invisibility Potion
• 5 Emeralds - Tree Saplings/Ender Pearl/Brush/Clock
• 36 Emeralds - Golden Apple
• 11 Emeralds - Healing Potion
• 10 Emeralds + Compass - Sea Explorer Map
• 13 Emeralds + Compass - Cave Explorer Map
• 13 Emeralds + Compass - Badlands Explorer Map
• 13 Emeralds + Compass - Ocean Explorer Map
• 14 Emeralds + Compass - Woodland Explorer Map
• 8 Emeralds + Compass - Swamp Explorer Map
• 10 Emeralds + Compass - Snowland Explorer Map
• 13 Emeralds + Compass - Nether Seeker Map
• 18 Emeralds + Compass - Duneland Explorer Map
• 18 Emeralds + Compass - Fortune Seeker Map
• 16 Emeralds + Compass - Jungle Explorer Map
• 1 Emerald - Mycelium
• 1 Emerald - 2 Moss Block
• 1 Emerald - 3 Glowstone Dust
• 2 Emeralds - Ferm. Spider Eye, Rabbit's Foot, Scute~~~~
• 2 Emeralds - 5 Flints/Ink Sacs/Glow Ink Sacs, Fire Charges
• 3 Emeralds - 8 Copper Ingots/8 Rabbit Hides
• 1 Emerald - 4 Breads
• 1 Emerald - 6 Cookies